Same Old, New Old

Quite a few bloggers casually mention that this is essentially the same team as last year. Some mention this as a reason to trash the optimism of other posters, and some mention this as an aside before going on to list how the team is slightly different and might therefore be just a teensy bit better this coming year.

Ahhhhhhemmmmmmm. Dig it out, fellas. This team is not slightly different than last year’s team, it is fundamentally different. At this time last year, Isaac Bruce was the #1 WR. That spot is now occupied by Michael Crabtree. That is a quantum leap in betterness. Last year, Shaun Hill was the QB, now it is Alex Smith. Once again, a vast improvement, regardless of what Smith haters feel about it. I doubt if there is anybody in the league who would not call Smith an improvement over Hill — certainly not the Defensive Coordinators of opposing teams who feasted on Hill’s limitations last year. These two improvements alone, at two of the most vital positions on a team, are reason enough to claim this team is different and it is significantly better.

However, we won’t stop there. Last year Dashon Goldson was an unproven 3rd year player starting at a crucial spot in the secondary. This year he’s a proven player and a very good one. Last year, Mark Roman was the dime DB, this year it will be a younger, faster, playmaking fellow named Reggie Smith. Last year, our DB depth included a rookie 7th round draft pick (Curtis Taylor) and this year that guy is Taylor Mays.

I will not go into the vast difference between who will be our LG and RT this year. It was covered quite extensively in the first round of this year’s draft. Or is someone out there going to tell me with a straight face that David Baas is going to beat out Mike Iupati and Adam Snyder will fend off Anthony Davis? Who is this rash and ridiculous fellow who would spurt forth such brazen horsecrap? Chilo Rachal will be entering his 3rd year and is not the same confused lumberjack that he was last year at this time. If improvement to 3/5ths of your O-line doesn’t qualify as pretty honking significant, then significance must have grown a different meaning from the one it has long had in Webster’s.

This team has three candidates with super speed who can take a kick off or a punt to the house. Last year there were none. This year, every member of the offense knows the playbook. Last year there were none who did. NONE. Is it really that hard to understand what a difference this tidbit will make on the team this year? For an enterprise requiring eleven gentlemen (okay, young adults) to be completely in sync about sixty times per game, sometimes in frantic situations, it is a huge difference. I don’t follow college football, but I am aware that “returning” players in the “same scheme” is considered to be a big plus for any team. Why don’t people who follow the 49ers give this any value?

Last year’s team had an OC who had to call plays for a team that didn’t know many of them, and for two different sets of teams during the course of the year. This kindly fellow took pretty much all of the abuse heaved at the offense’s production last year and never lost his cool or his humor. Clearly, SOME of the blame for the problems with the offense fell upon the players themselves not executing the plays. Why would anyone expect the offense to be the same or less this year when the OC can call more plays and have guys who can execute those plays better than they could a year ago?

The 49ers also have two new O-line coaches this year, Mike Solari and Ray Brown. These gentlemen are quite highly thought of throughout the league and by the players. They replace a guy who did not seem to have much luck here getting the O-line to mesh and play well. Perhaps that was the O-line’s fault, but only the “playing well” part, which never seemed to experience any growth. Meshing (i.e., having a clue) would be more attributable to the coaching.

So, once again, is this the same team as last year? Nubba dubba, bubba!!!



wordpress stats plugin


Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Mindless Drivel
11 comments on “Same Old, New Old
  1. BergerNo Gravatar says:

    I say use David Baas for 3rd and short/goal line FB and cut Norris. Use Brit Miller as an all-purpose FB for when we go 21. That would help right there.

  2. SkeebersNo Gravatar says:

    Gotta have a bit of sympathy for Baas. Drafted #1 in Round 2 in 2005, sits his rookie year, in comes Larry Allen, so he sits 2nd & 3rd years, then gets hurt in years 4 & 5, now Iupati comes in, relegating Baas to a backup role during his contract year. Somebody stuck the Voodoo pin in his doll.

  3. BergerNo Gravatar says:

    I think Baas gets injured playing checkers.

  4. unca_chuckNo Gravatar says:

    And yes, Snyder likely beats AD coming out of camp.

    Davis will probably need til the bye week to crack the starting lineup.

  5. BergerNo Gravatar says:

    I just read that AD was in the training facility every day since OTA’s were done. They say he looks great. Iupati and Mays have been there every day too.

  6. SkeebersNo Gravatar says:

    Anybody watch the State of the Franchise on 49ers.com last night? I never used to pay much attention to these PR shows, but duty calls now. Best question was who would win a throwback Nutcracker between Singletary and Rathman. Sing said you would have to ask Tom. It would be a good one, though, no doubt.

  7. unca_chuckNo Gravatar says:

    All good news, Reno. If nothing, Singletary has these guys wanting to get after it.

    That, and good coaching? This is a solid playoff team.

  8. unca_chuckNo Gravatar says:

    And, no, I missed it.

    Giants game and all . . .

  9. FranchiseNo Gravatar says:

    Seeing “Chilo Rachal” in your post just gave me an “oh I forgot about that Guard”. That’s the kind of depth we have now on our O-line. Can’t wait for Iupati to start cracking coconuts.

  10. SkeebersNo Gravatar says:

    Yeah, Franchise, Chilo is kind of flying under the radar right now. But when he was drafted, people were very high on him. Singletary said he could be really special. He might surprise people this year and turn into as dominant a RG as many expect Iupati to do on the left.

  11. unca_chuckNo Gravatar says:

    Rachal has shown flashes of good surrounded by ehhhh. His upside is there though.

2019 Schedule
9-8: @ Tampa Bay Buccaneers, 1:25pm
9-15: @ Cincinnati Bengals, 10am
9-22: vs. Pittsburgh Steelers, 1:25pm
9-29: BYE

10-7: vs. Cleveland Browns, 5:15pm
10-13: @ Los Angeles Rams, 1:05pm
10-20: @ Washington, 10am
10-27: vs. Carolina Panthers, 1:05pm
10-31: @ Arizona Cardinals, 5:20pm

11-11: vs. Seattle Seahawks, 5:15pm
11-17: vs. Arizona Cardinals, 1:05pm
11-24: vs. Green Bay Packers, 1:25pm

12-1: @ Baltimore Ravens, 10am
12-8: @ New Orleans Saints, 10am
12-15: vs. Atlanta Falcons, 1:25pm
12-21 or 12-22: vs. Los Angeles Rams
12-29: @ Seattle Seahawks, 1:25pm

2019 Draft Class
1. DE Nick Bosa, Ohio State
2. WR Deebo Samuel, South Carolina
3. WR Jalen Hurd, Baylor
4. P Mitch Wishnowsky, Utah
5. LB Dre Greenlaw, Arkansas
6. TE Kaden Smith, Stanford
6. OT Justin Skule, Vanderbilt
6. DB Tim Harris, Virginia
 
2018 Prognostications
Closest to the Pin:
  Mr Fletch: 7-9

Bakkentom: 8-8
Grumpy: 8-8
Winder: 8-8
Bullit: 9-7
NJ49er: 9-7
Skeebers: 10-6
Spitblood: 0-16
Rob!!!: 16-0

Archives